Walmart, Ethics & the Law

Walmart announced that Daniel Trujillo came on board last week (2012.10.29) as SVP and Chief Compliance Officer for Walmart International. It’s a new post and part of a restructuring of the retail giant’s legal structure. General Counsel Jeff Gearhart now heads compliance, legal, ethics, and investigations ops, according to published reports. They also added Jay Jorgensen, an attorney, as Global Chief Compliance Officer and FBI veteran Tracy Reinhold, as VP Global Investigations.

This reflects a flurry of activity triggered by the exposure of what looks like their widespread use of bribery in Mexico. If true it would open Walmart to charges under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). Earlier this year (2012.02.21) in an in-depth investigative piece, The New York Times painted a picture of bribery fueling Walmart’s growth in Mexico. Tens of millions were paid to overcome any obstacle in their effort to fast-track new store construction across the country. It worked; twenty percent of the world’s Walmart stores are now in Mexico.

Walmart employees in Mexico who tried to alert headquarters “Carpet-Landers” were ignored or marginalized. When the top leaders could no longer turn a blind eye to the problem they did their best to minimize the issue. Their Investigations Unit was rebuked for being “overly aggressive” by then Walmart CEO, H. Lee Scott Jr., who is still on their Board of Directors. A few days later their report was shipped to Walmart’s Mexican headquarters never to be mentioned again.

These new hires and this consolidation in the headquarters legal office looks like an extension of the cover-up that has been at the core of Walmart’s response to the bribery scandal. Looking at their newly minted SVP, and Chief Compliance Officer for Wal-Mart International, Daniel Trujillo’s chief qualification for the job is pretty obvious. He was Chief Compliance Officer at oilfield services company Schlumberger Ltd. Our Justice Department just bailed on a bribery investigation involving Schlumberger, an outcome Walmart is probably hoping for.

There are a couple things wrong here. Compliance and ethics don’t belong in the same basket. Compliance has to do with the law; ethics falls way outside what’s legal. It’s about corporate culture and reputation. The corporate communications folks deal in that arena. Were Walmart really interested in fixing this problem, they would be focused on new hires to create a culture to repair their reputation.

You would think that the 2006 Hewlett-Packard Board of Directors spying case would burn that into the minds of every major corporation. Kevin Hunsaker, HP Senior Counsel and Director of Ethics and Standards of Business Conduct, green-lighted a stupid telephone spying operation. He thought it was legal, it wasn’t. Hunsaker and several others were charged with a felony; he pleaded no contest. From an ethics viewpoint this plan wasn’t even close to being OK, but that’s not the viewpoint lawyers work from. Ethics and reputation are not in their skill set.