Powered By Blogger

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Whose Money Is It Anyway?

Occasionally we get to see the folks on Wall Street actually engaged in the job we expect them to carry out, creating capital. All of the other nonsense that takes up most of their time –trading bogus investment instruments, pawning them off on unsuspecting clients and then laying bets that they will fail– are not interrupted, of course, but some social good does bubble up to the surface of the slime pit in lower Manhattan from time to time.

Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) are perhaps the most visible benefit provided by the monster (in all defining aspects of that word) banks like Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs and the three or four other names we have become painfully aware of since they sent us crashing into a recession in 2008.  They gleefully took our money to forestall a world-wide economic collapse. And while we are slowly climbing out of the crater they left us in, they are doing very well thank you, making money hand over fist.

Actually they are doing exactly what they were doing before, the same things that dumped us into the sewer. We thought our money was supposed to help small businesses and other job creating stuff. But that’s hard and it’s so much easier to succumb to their gambling habit of old. That’s what some folks see even creeping into the IPOs that are beginning to turn up again on Wall Street.

Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley were hired by LinkedIn, the B2B social media site, to take the company public. The banks’ role was to evaluate LinkedIn and judge what the market would pay; their figure was $45.00 each for the just under eight million shares in the offering. That netted LinkedIn about $350 million, a healthy infusion of capital. However, the $45.00 turned out to be way low; by the end of the first day the stock had rocketed up 110%. In fact the minute it went on the market it jumped over 80%. So the investment bank’s customers and a few others bought low and probably sold high, doubling their money in one day. Money that some believe should have gone to LinkedIn.

It’s easy to tag Merrill & Morgan as the bad guys. With their fingers on the pulse of the market they should have known the run-up would be huge. On the other hand, LinkedIn was the first of the social media companies to go public. With a yet-to-be proven business model that only pushed $16 million to its bottom line last year, LinkedIn was hardly a slam-dunk to rocket into Wall Street Stardom. When you take into account that the Street still has the dot.com bubble in its rear view mirror, the $45 price doesn’t look so bad. Had the banks overpriced the shares and seen them plummet when they hit the market, the legal beagles in the banks would have been busy for years defending a storm of lawsuits.

There is an alternative, an auction that allows the investors, the market, to set the price. While that description is a bit too simple, the auction model IPO seems a better path. It doesn’t take the banks out of the process completely, but it does give the company a lot more control over who gains from the offering. Take away for the other IPOs in the wings? An auction will put more of your money in your pocket.

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Too Big to Jail?


When a covey of executives from Goldman Sachs appeared before the Senate Permanent Investigations Subcommittee in Washington, they first stood up and swore to tell the “Truth, etc., etc.” When the committee’s 650-page report was released, it seemed pretty clear that they did not tell any part of the truth let alone the whole truth. Already under attack by the S.E.C., Goldman is now facing charges from multiple sources.

We are all tired to death of grandstanding members of the Congress and their “Gotcha” hearings. Senator Carl Levin, Chairman of the Permanent Investigations Subcommittee, does not fall into that classification. Levin has a law degree from Harvard and experience as Michigan’s Special Assistant Attorney General. He doesn’t do “Gotcha.”

That said, the appearance of the Goldman Sachs “Carpetland” crew, including CEO Lloyd Blankfein, in front of Levin’s committee pretty much turned into just such an outing. The Senator turned over the results of their investigation to the Justice Department suggesting that they review as to bringing perjury charges. While we claim no legal insight, what Blankfein and his associates said under oath and what they said in internal documents obtained by the Committee are vastly different.

The Justice Department has taken no action. We would assume they are building a case. After all, they are putting baseball legend Roger Clemens on trial for exactly the same offense –lying to the Congress while under oath– with seemingly little more than the word of Clemens’ one time trainer. While lying to the Congress under any circumstances is a bad thing, whether or not a sports figure shot up some performance enhancing drugs is not quite in the same class as involvement in triggering the derailment of our economy.

Meanwhile New York's newly minted state Attorney General, Eric Schneiderman, is charging ahead with an investigation into the role played by several major investment banks –including Goldman Sachs– in triggering the financial collapse. And Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr. has issued subpoenas to Goldman for records relating to the 2008 crisis.

The New York based prosecutors have a unique tool, the 1921 Martin Act, a state law aimed at curbing financial fraud. Schneiderman and Vance could use the Martin Act along with information gleaned from an S.E.C. and two federal investigations to help build cases against the individuals who created worthless financial instruments and conned buyers into paying top dollar for them.

Many Wall Street lawyers seem to believe that nothing much but some slap-on-the-wrist fines will come of this. They are sure nobody will go to jail or even end up with “Felon” attached to their name. That would be a tragedy; it would do nothing to deter a repeat of the reckless behavior that ran us off the cliff.

After all, if we are going after sports heroes for lying about behavior that resulted in fooling their fans, how can we justify not holding those accountable who appear to have thrown us into a recession that has wracked our nation to its core. What’s good enough for Roger Clemens is good enough for Lloyd Blankfein and the others who appeared before Senator Levin’s committee. We deserve their day in court.

We Have No Mandate to Spin


Anyone who has ever watched a cop show is familiar with the “Read ‘em their rights” routine. “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to speak to an attorney, and to have an attorney present during any questioning. If you cannot afford a lawyer, one will be provided for you.”

I don’t see any reference to any right to public relations counsel in there. That’s why I was stunned by a Reuters story outlining the “Dream Team” of lawyers, private eyes, and public relations practitioners Dominique Strauss-Kahn is assembling to defend himself against charges of sexual assault. He is, of course, innocent until proven guilty of these charges; however, at best he has a reputation as an outrageous womanizer. Now I understand -and I agree- that he is entitled to all the lawyers and gumshoes his millions can buy, but why would anyone in the reputation business (that’s us, isn’t it?) want to be associated with Strauss-Kahn or this mess?

Occasionally a long-time client is ensnared in some illegal activity, mostly unjustly, sometimes through stupidity, or an act of a rogue employee. In that case we would want to be on the team, although our counsel would likely be dramatically different from what the Strauss-Kahn team is looking for. Sadly, many who fly the public relations flag are happy to work with anyone and follow whatever agenda the folks with the cash are looking for.

Most communications pros recognize their role as a “Canary in the Coal Mine,” on guard to sniff out the slightest hint of reputation damaging activity and roadblock it before it can tarnish our employer or client. However, there are a minority of spin-doctors and worse who bring shame on all the good guys. Unfortunately, a few of the largest firms in the business fall into the latter group.

One of our professional organizations, the PRSA, has the good work it does diminished by its toothless ethics code. They enable the pond-scum that clings to us all to brazenly fly the PRSA flag and puff themselves up showing-off their PRSA issued credentials. Meanwhile the rest of us have to share the same tent and put up with the stench.

What we have in this situation is a 32-year-old widow, struggling to support her daughter on a hotel maid’s income, stacked up against all the guns a multimillionaire big shot can bring to play against her. It’s already started; they’ve put out the word that she lives in an apartment complex reserved for HIV/AIDS folk. Score one for the Strauss-Kahn Dream Team; it’s just the first salvo in the Dream Team’s efforts to demonize this young woman.

Of course no one mentions that she is from West Africa and was granted asylum in the United States; facts that explain the HIV/AIDS issue quite nicely. But still, what chance does she have? At the end of the day, if they are successful in this assault on the assaulted, all those who toil where they might encounter the mighty will be afraid to report future assaults.

Wouldn’t it be nice if one of our discipline’s heavyweights signed on pro bono to act as a truth squad and protect this woman in the media? Wouldn’t they have fun crossing swords with the best that Strauss-Kahn can throw at her? 

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Don’t Mess With the Little Folk


Urban Outfitters operates a couple hundred retail outlets worldwide offering a range of  kitcehy goods from housewares to shoes to clothing and more, under six brand names. Their appeal is to teens and twenty-somethings striving to be “Hip,” whatever that means these days. It is a remarkable success story launched by Richard Hayne (now worth $1.8 billion) in 1970 with a single store on the campus of the University of Pennsylvania.

According to a piece in the Huffington Post and other sources, Urban Outfitters is caught up in an intellectual property dustup with Stevie Koerner, a Chicago based designer selling her jewelry online. She has a line of handmade silver pendants, many in the shape of some of the 50 states, a few countries and several continents. They all have a heart cut out; she calls these her “World/United States of Love” line.

So one day a design similar to her New York State pendant shows up in an Urban Outfitters’ store. Not cool, thinks Stevie, but not much I can do about it. She tweets a complaint with her sad tale and soon a “Boycott Urban Outfitters” movement begins. Before long Twitter is trending heavy with the message and it goes viral worldwide. Unconfirmed reports indicate that Urban Outfitters pulled their version from the stores tout de suite.

This is not the first instance of a ripoff design showing up in Urban Outfitters’ stores. A year ago The Brooklyn Paper and The Village Voice ran stories about similar design ripoffs involving Urban Outfitters. The issue has not escaped Urban Outfitters; reportedly they are now asking suppliers if their designs have been “inspired” by others. Given Ms. Koerner’s recent experience that message hasn’t done much to cure the problem. Perhaps a plainspoken, “If we find that you ripped this design off from someone, we will make you eat it and you will never sell us another dime’s worth of anything” might do the trick.

Getting the ripoff of Ms. Koerner’s design out of Urban Outfitters is apparently just the beginning of a reversal in her fortune. A note on her website, www.IMakeShinyThings.com tells it all: “Thank you SO much for the support everyone! Orders will take a bit longer due to the overwhelming response to Urban Outfitters! Please give me 3-4 weeks to create and ship your items! Xo.” Seems that taking on the giant retailer has raised her profile and business is booming. Good for her!

In Tom Friedman’s Flat World the lesson for Urban Outfitters and others in a similar position –is– don’t mess with the little folk; they can organize an army of supporters and even make billionaires back down. The lesson for the little folk like Stevie Koerner –is– don’t take it lying down; use Twitter and all the social media to go after anyone who has wronged you. The message for the rest of us –is– it is a new day, a brighter, nicer, kinder, more ethical day.

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

WhisperGate


Things don’t sink much lower than having the guardians of reputation forgetting that reputation is their sole reason for existence. Despite what some believe, the vast majority of public relations practitioners are not a bunch of smarmy spin doctors. They value nothing more than their ability to be the “Canary in the Coal Mine,” sniffing out the slightest hint of an action that might damage the reputation of their company or their client.  

That’s what makes a blatant attack on Google engineered and carried out by PR giant Burson-Marsteller on behalf of Facebook so mindboggling. Tagged “WhisperGate” by the media –perhaps because of its resemblance to a nasty grade school rumor– it’s hard to understand how anyone thought this was a good idea. The fact that two guys who recently moved into the PR world from fairly senior positions in journalism were badmouthing Google to their contacts in the media makes it even harder to fathom.

What level of hubris made them think they could carry off this kind of nonsense? What journalist or ex-journalist would fail to see this going public and viral in the blink of an eye; as it did? Their phone calls were stupid; pushing their garbage in emails was insane. How long did they think it would take for someone to forward their own words to the world? Who did they think they were?

Of course we have no way of knowing how this all came about, or whose idea it was in the first place. We are not likely to discover how many others –alongside, or up the food chain– were involved. But it does lead us to take a look at Burson-Marsteller. A quick perusal of their history and website leaves one less than impressed with their ethical grounding. To their credit they swore off tobacco last year (2010) after shilling for Philip Morris and other industry players for years. Among other things, they set up what were made to look like independent scientific entities to cast doubt on the dangers of smoking.

They lay claim to crisis management credentials springing from the 1982 Tylenol tragedy in Chicago. In a carefully parsed paragraph they say, “Burson-Marsteller worked closely with Johnson & Johnson.”  To our knowledge all the smarts that have become the gold standard for dealing with this kind of catastrophic happening came solely from J&J. Burson-Marsteller certainly played no part in setting the course J&J chose.   

The Burson-Marsteller Google attack delivered a black eye to every public relations practitioner, the good and the bad. Sadly, the good guys have no way to distance themselves from the smarmy elements in their discipline. As Warren Buffett famously said, “It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it;” in this case for somebody else to ruin it. Burson-Marsteller will shrug off this despicable incident and go on to the next smarmy tactic, seemingly their only regret that they got caught. Meanwhile the good guys will suffer.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Reputation, Reputation, Reputation!


Harris Interactive rolled out their 12th annual Reputation Quotient® (RQ®) last week (5/2/11). They compiled the views of 30,104 Americans to determine what Harris describes as the “public’s positive perception” of  “the 60 most visible companies in the United States.” It is great news that overall these well-known companies have earned a dramatically improved image in this year’s rankings.

Google sits atop the Harris RQ® study for the first time. Certainly no big surprise given the company’s well-known drive to be good guys. It’s no surprise either to find the big banks at the other end of the scale with Goldman Sachs leading the race to the bottom. Actually, Goldman is the major loser across the board. They were buoyed slightly by a few of the study respondents who –can you imagine– saw Goldman as a good place to invest. In the same vein, however, Goldman was rated the very least likely to be recommended; probably by those investors Goldman hammered.

Goldman Sachs’ view from the sewer doubtless makes it hard for them to even see the top of the Harris Sixty. However, in the unlikely event that they should ever glance in that direction with a mind to improving their reputation, they might try practicing Google’s informal motto, “Don’t be evil.”

Actually, more companies than ever are striving and succeeding in bettering their reputation. The number of companies that attained the Harris “Gold Standard” RQ® score of 80 or above increased dramatically to an all-time record high this year. It almost tripled from 6 in 2010 to 16 in 2011. Three factors drove the reputations of these list toppers: transparency, ethics, and performance. This is the first time ever that there have been more than a handful of companies at this level.

There are ten companies that have scored above 75 for the last ten years or more. That kind of consistent reputation maintenance shows a true commitment to doing the right thing.  No surprises here: Johnson & Johnson, Coca Cola, 3M, Procter & Gamble, Sony, General Mills, UPS, FedEx, Microsoft & Kraft Foods. The 2011 study has 27 companies with an RQ® above 75, and a 28th just below that bar. While the number of companies scoring 80 and above grew dramatically, the number of companies that scored 75 or better was only up one this year over last from 26 to 27; about half of the Sixty.  The bottom half of the list seems to be made up of those who haven’t gotten the message that, “ethics works.”

In nearly every ranking you are once again looking at the same cast of characters–including the bottom feeders.Leading that gang Goldman Sachs is the least trusted company in the 2011 Harris RQ® Study. Sachs and four other big banks take half of the ten spots in the bottom rank among those respondents who say they would “definitely not” trust these companies. The other five are a dog’s breakfast of oil, chemical, and cable television companies along with one of the biggest insurers on the planet, AIG.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

When the Rich are Worried!

It’s easy to understand the need to encourage economic growth and other socially beneficial outcomes with tax breaks. The problem arises when tax policies have unintended outcomes or provide an unfair advantage to one group over another. And oft-times a tax policy starts out working fine but over time it no longer makes sense.

Take our duties on imported sugar. We have driven the price of sugar in the United States to astronomical levels. In addition to impacting the cost of sweetening one’s “morning-joe,” this has greatly sweetened the lives of a handful of sugar plantation owners. Worse, these tariffs have driven nearly every major candy maker out of the country.  Just take a drive up the Queen Elizabeth Way between Fort Erie & Toronto; you can see where much of the candy we enjoy is now made. Oh, and by the way, the Canadians are thrilled with the tens of thousands of jobs we pushed their way.  

On a different note, some of the laws enacted over the last +/-100 years (yes, they go back to 1913) intended to encourage oil exploration are no longer in our interest. We are giving the oil companies billions of taxpayer dollars to do what most companies do with their own funds.

High oil and gasoline prices have suddenly focused attention on these perks; especially when the mega oil companies are reporting spectacular profits. Understand, there is nothing illegal about any of this, but there is a clear ethical line that seems to have been left in the rear view mirror. No one questions any business’s right -even their responsibility- to seek out the help of their elected representatives when they need help.

On the other hand, once the need has passed, don’t they have a responsibility to advise their government contacts that they no longer are in need? Instead the oil companies are fighting to keep billions in tax breaks. That’s not need, that’s greed. They are all quick to say that they are not causing the run up in oil prices. In fact everyone connected with oil has disavowed responsibility. Furthermore, there is no shortage of oil; nor has there been any interruption in the supply chain.

Then why is this plentiful resource so expensive? The experts seem to agree that the culprit is speculation. It appears that the super wealthy seized on the unrest in the Middle East and rushed into the commodity markets creating a price tsunami in oil. While the speculators are lining their pockets, they are emptying ours at the gas pumps. Worse, increased fuel costs are hitting us everywhere from the grocery store to the home store and threatening to derail the recovery.

Some of the well intended deregulation efforts and tax policies of the last two decades are whipping through our economy with devastating impact on the little folks. When you have large numbers of the very wealthy calling for an end to tax breaks for the rich – shouldn’t we listen? It isn’t that they don’t want the money; the rich see this imbalance endangering our economy. It’s too bad this viewpoint escapes those in charge of setting tax policy.