Comes the Revolution

IR Alert
The Journal of Investor Relations

January 21, 2010


CEO Compensation will be in our shareholders' crosshairs this year

Anyone in our discipline who believes that public outrage will end at financial sector bonuses is whistling through the graveyard. Executive compensation will be the next target and our shareholders will hit us hard. Anytime the gap between those at the top of our economic food chain and those further down grows too wide, folks rebel.

Teddy Roosevelt became perhaps the most successful occupant of the White House in the twentieth century riding such a rebellion. The former Rough Rider rode roughshod over arguably the most powerful businessmen in our history.

A trustbuster president and master politician led the first revolution during the last century. Growing in the background even as Teddy spoke softly and carried a big stick was the American Federation of Labor. Labor pioneer Samuel Gompers gathered a group of disparate trade unions together under one banner. His dream laid the foundation for John L. Lewis to leverage his position as head of the Coal Miner's UMWA into the head of the AFL-CIO and a partnership with another Roosevelt, Franklin D. This revolution carried up to World War II and created a major portion of middleclass America during the last half of the twentieth century.

That same time span, however, saw the roots of another revolution-inspiring trend: ballooning salaries at the top of America's corporate structure. At the end of World War II, these executives earned salaries that allowed room for fair compensation to the middle management and those below. In the ensuing decades, however, executive pay scales have grown way out of proportion to those at the other end of the scale.

Depending on whose figures you use, just the last thirty years have seen a huge disparity emerging. In the early 1980s, CEOs were earning about forty times as much as their average hourly employee. Today they are earning ten to twenty times that much; five hundred times as much is common and a thousand times as much is not unheard of.

Not only that, they are paying a smaller percentage of their income in taxes than those at the bottom of the scale. Who says so? Warren Buffett, who issued this challenge in a 2007 interview on NBC television: "I'll bet a million dollars against any member of the Forbes 400 who challenges me that the average (federal tax rate including income and payroll taxes) for the Forbes 400 will be less than the average of their receptionists." So far he has had no takers, because he's right.

What does that mean for us? It means that not just the folks on the street are fed up with executive compensation. The shareholders we face day to day are increasingly going to raise this issue, and what we're hearing this week tied to banking bonuses is just the tip of the iceberg. We need to be ready, and we need to know the numbers, be it for our CEO or the CEOs of our clients. We need to know the ratio of our top folks versus the hourly folks, and yes, we need to know the tax rate they pay and how it compares to those who greet our visitors (and our shareholders) when they walk up to the reception desk.

Then, as trusted advisors, we need to have a heart to heart with our CEOs.