The Return of the Robber-Barons

The Return of the Robber-Barons

At the dawn of the 20th century America experienced unprecedented change. The young were moving off the farms into the cities. Steel, rail, and oil giants wrought permanent change; change that created a chasm between the wealthy few and the vast number of Americans struggling far below.

Into this moment stepped Theodore Roosevelt.  A brash young President who recognized that a nation so divided could never achieve the greatness that would allow its people to thrive. His trust-busting crusade initiated a series of legal restraints on the robber-barons culminating in the Glass–Steagall Acts of 1932 and 1933. These boundaries, along with labor laws and a variety of safety nets, allowed our free enterprise system –and our people– to thrive and grow.

The loosening of those restraints as the 20^th century faded into the 21st brought a return of the practices they were designed to control. A study of the effect of wide spread deregulation was ordered several years ago by Senators Max Baucus and Charles Grassley, then ranking members of the Senate Finance Committee. The Congressional Budget Office delivered the study just last week. Its findings paint a bleak picture: the middle class is fast shrinking while those on the bottom are sinking farther away from those on the top of the pile.

Over the last few decades the top 1% of Americans enjoyed a 275% jump in their income. The bottom 20% not so much, they gained 18%. Do the math, 275% is over 15 times greater than 18%. The report points to the move from progressive income taxes to payroll taxes, easing the tax burden on those with the 275% gain while increasing the tax rate of those who have seen a measly 18% improvement.

As the giants of industry are quick to point out, our corporate taxes are among the highest in the world. However, since most of them have successfully lobbied their way out of paying taxes at the local, state and federal level, the federal tax rate has little or no effect on the corporate titans. Our hefty corporate rate does hit small businesses – the folks who are struggling to stay afloat in the aftermath of the collapse triggered by the bankers’ reckless gambling.

Since everyone agrees that small businesses create jobs, we find ourselves taxing these job creators, while the Fortune 500 (who rang up a net job loss over the last twenty years) pay little taxes, if any. The banks we bailed out are swimming in profits generated from the same risky games that got us into this mess. Weren’t they were supposed to help small businesses who want to grow and create jobs? What happened to that?

Meanwhile the top 1% (the 275% folks) are investing overseas or gambling on commodities (like oil – boosting gas prices and adding to the woes of the poor) all the while giving luxury marketers like Tiffany’s a boost. Sales in Tiffany’s New York flagship store increased 41% in the second quarter ending in July, up 33% thus far for the year. Tiffany’s stores worldwide are booming as well, thank you.

If you missed the ethical issues in this scenario, read it again.

W.T.”Bill” McKibben is a Buffalo based author. © 2011 GLG